Below is a listing of all Vanderbilt players who have received All-America recognition during their time at Vanderbilt. Past players who received Freshman All-America honors are not a part of this list.
Jeff Peeples
Pitcher, 1973
Scottie Madison
Catcher, 1980
Joey Cora
Shortstop, 1984, 1985
Greg Thomas
First Base, 1991
Vee Hightower
Center Field, 1993
Boomer Whipple
Third Base, 1993, 1994
Clinton Johnston
Outfield/Pitcher, 1998
Hunter Bledsoe
Third Base, 1999
Warner Jones
Second Base, 2004
Pedro Alvarez
Third Base, 2006, 2007
David Price
Pitcher, 2006, 2007
Dominic de la Osa
Outfielder, 2007
Casey Weathers
Pitcher, 2007
Jason Esposito
Third Base, 2011
Grayson Garvin
Pitcher, 2011
Aaron Westlake
First Base, 2011
Tyler Beede
Pitcher, 2013
Tony Kemp
Second Base, 2013
Brian Miller
Pitcher, 2013
Mike Yastrzemski
Outfield, 2013
Kevin Ziomek
Pitcher, 2013
Dansby Swanson
Second Base, 2014
Shortstop, 2015
Carson Fulmer
Starting Pitcher, 2015
Jeren Kendall
Outfielder, 2016
Kyle Wright
Pitcher, 2017